DJ and Kimmy reunite with old flames and enemies at their high school reunion, leading DJ to wonder if she still has feelings for Steve, who reveals his intentions of proposing to CJ.
Meanwhile, Jackson creates a fake report card to make it appear he is a straight-A student and later tels Stephanie he feels like he's the only family member that isn't special.
The episode title comes from Romy and Michele's High School Reunion, a 1997 comedy film.
D.J. notes that she was voted "Most Likely to Marry Lance Bass". However, Bass and NSYNC would have been complete unknowns, when D.J. and Kimmy graduated high school in 1995. (NSYNC's debut album was released in 1997, 2 years after their graduation.)